Mostrando las entradas con la etiqueta metáfora digital. Mostrar todas las entradas
Mostrando las entradas con la etiqueta metáfora digital. Mostrar todas las entradas

lunes, octubre 20, 2008

It's the SAME cell environment, stupid

A recent commentary in Science titled "It's the sequence, stupid" describes the conclusions of an experiment published within the journal's latest issue. Framed as a supposed slap in the face to epigenetics, the experiment describes what happens with some indicators of "gene expression" of human chromosome 21 in mouse hepatocytes; that is, human c21 has been incorporated into the genome of an experimental line of mice. They find that things such as the binding site of several transcription factors, and the general levels of transcription on the chromosome, are for the most (but not entirely) the same as in human hepatocytes. Their conclusion? The sequence of the human C21, rather than the epigenetic cell environment, is mostly responsible for "regulation" of its own expression. Hence, "It's the sequence, stupid".
But, is it? It is well-known that all cells within the body contain the same sequence, but express very differently in different cell types, because of the different cell environments. It is interesting that the people at Science managed to wash this fact out of their brains, since it directly refutes that expression is determined in the sequence. Further, their conclusion is simply not logical because they are comparing cells with the exact same cell phenotype. The image shows micrographies from two liver sections; one is from mouse, the other is from human. Can anyone tell me which is which? The fact is, at the cell-histological level, most homologous tissues of mouse and human are undistinguishable.
Don't expect virtually identical cells to produce great differences in the expression of the same sequence just because you are comparing them in different species. Expect them to produce virtually identical gene expression. As simple as that.

Refs:
Wilson, M.D., Barbosa-Morais, N.L., Schmidt, D., Conboy, C.M., Vanes, L., Tybulewicz, V.L.J. Fisher, E.M.C., Tavaré, S., and Odom. D.T. 2008 Species-Specific Transcription in Mice Carrying Human Chromosome 21. Science 322: 434-438

Coller HA, Kruglyak L.
2008 Genetics.It's the sequence, stupid! Science. 322:380-1.

UPDATE

Check out this site on hepatocyte histology
Left is pig; right is raccoon
Phenotypic plasticity: This is mouse, fasted and glycogen-enriched
And of course, human (from another site):

martes, julio 22, 2008

What is so informative about information?

What is so informative about information?
Carlos M. Hamame, Diego Cosmelli, and Francisco Aboitiz (2007) . Comentario sobre: "Précis of Evolution in Four Dimensions" Eva Jablonka and Marion J lamb
Behavioral and Brain Sciences 30: 371 – 372

Abstract: Understanding evolution beyond a gene-centered vision is a fertile ground for new questions and approaches. However, in this systemic perspective, we take issue with the necessity of the concept of information. Through the example of brain and language evolution, we propose the autonomous systems theory as a more biologically relevant framework for the evolutionary perspective offered by Jablonka & Lamb

Hablando del tremendo daño a Chile con que según Medel (2008) carga el legado de Maturana, ya mencionaba anteriormente que por aquel fatídico templo de endoctrinamiento que era el lab "el rayo" había pasado Francisco Aboitiz. Ahora, entiéndase bien: Aboitiz tiene "ADN" darwinista. Al menos donde quedamos la última vez, la cuestión era la selección natural, y le molestaba el manejo de M&M de ese tema.

En realidad, pasar por el lab de Maturana no es un lavado de cerebro. Cada cual termina recogiendo lo que le guste, aunque no esté de acuerdo con otra cosa. Por lo general, se quedan con algo. Es por eso que fue grato leer el artículo arriba citado, donde estos autores producen una elegante crítica de Jablonka y Lamb muy en sintonía con nuestra forma de pensar:

"However, while the authors dispute the gene-centered notion and consider evolution as a systemic multilayered phenomenon, we believe they fall short in one critical aspect: J&L rely heavily on the notion of “information transmission” in a rather loose manner. Their approach is liable to the argument that in order to have any such thing, one needs a transmitter, a message, and a receiver – something that is not easily found when dealing with biological phenomena"

"One influential hypothesis states that living systems are those that maintain organizational closure: they are constituted by networks of self-sustaining processes, regardless of the materials used to instantiate such loops; that is, they are autonomous systems (Maturana & Varela 1973; Varela 1979). When one understands organisms this way, the notion of information transmission becomes less appealing: a closed system cannot “have” information in itself"

El artículo de Hamame et al 2007 está en el grupoyahoo bajo el nombre "Précis of Evolution in Four Dimensions" Muy recomendado

viernes, enero 25, 2008

Más de la "metáfora digital"

Número 1:
Researchers at the J. Craig Venter Institute (JCVI) in Rockville, Md., report in the online edition of Science that they pieced together the genes of Mycoplasma genitalium, the smallest free-living bacterium that can be grown in the laboratory and a common culprit in urinary tract infections.
"This completes the second step of a three-step process in creating a synthetic organism," Gibson says. The first step came last summer when JCVI scientists transformed one species of bacteria into another with a DNA transplant, switching the identity of one bug by impregnating it with another's genetic code. The second step, constructing a synthetic bacterial genome, has now been accomplished with this study. The final step will involve inserting the synthetic genome into a cell and bringing it to life; Gibson says experiments with this goal are currently underway.
"The ultimate step is proving what they have synthesized is biologically active," says Eckard Wimmer, a molecular biologist at Stony Brook University in Long Island, N.Y., who led the effort to construct synthetic polio, the first synthetically built virus. "Unfortunately, this very critical point is missing here."
Regardless of what approach yields the most return, synthetic biology is, no doubt, racing forward. In the last few years DNA synthesis techniques have become faster, cheaper and accessible to more people. Ordering DNA from commercial outfits has become as easy as ordering pizza, according to Voigt, who projects that in upcoming decades scientists will be able to whip up much larger segments of DNA: synthetic genomes for yeast, animals--perhaps even humans. (Tomado de Scientific American, 24 de Enero de 2008)
Número 2:
Nuevamente en estos dos artículos, así como en muchos otros respecto a la última "papita" de Venter se recurre tanto para el público especialista como al común y de boca de difusores como de los expertos a la "metáfora digital" al tratamiento del genoma como un programa o software y que el paso de la Biología Sintética es insertar ese software en un hardware, consideremos por un minuto que un organismo no está determinado por su genoma... mmmmm... los desafíos de esta clase de desarrollo tecnológico (además de los aspectos éticos) se incrementan pues a más que "instalar" el genoma. Cuando vuelve a ser un tema vemos renacer un determinismo genético (no en el aspecto social que acusase Gould en desmedro de ciertas razas sino un determinismo a los organismos y a la biodiversidad en general) impulsado por iniciativas como el viaje de exploración del Sorcerer II de Venter; un nuevo Challenger o Beagle lo bautizó, pero ¿basta secuencias genomas de bichos por todo el mundo para entender la diversidad biológica?.

miércoles, diciembre 26, 2007

Muerte de la "metáfora digital"

Hay autores que pese a entender cuestiones profundas sobre la biología, muestran graves desaciertos. Me parece que un ejemplo es cómo tanto Mayr como Jacob promocionaron el uso de una "metáfora digital", donde se compara al ser vivo con un computador, como una forma casi literal de comprender lo que sucedía con el ADN en el organismo. El ADN sería comparable a un "programa" cuya ejecución daba por resultado al fenotipo.

Si bien esta visión combinaba el entusiasmo genocentrista con el entusiamso por las computadoras, el planteamiento presenta problemas filosóficos básicos. La codificación de información en el computador es definida por el usuario y sólo tiene sentido para el usuario, en el contexto de las preguntas que quiera resolver. Un ábaco provee un ejemplo claro: el asignar valores a los diferentes colores es lo que nos permite hacer operaciones simples que sabemos nos entregará los resultados correctos.
No es muy difíci darse cuenta que la manera en que opera el ADN en la celúla probablemente es muy distinta y poco comparable a la forma en que los seres humanos utilizan máquinas para procesar información codificada.

La dudosa utilidad de la metáfora digital también se ve evidenciada por lo pequeñito que ha resultado ser el genoma humano; es más pequeño que windows XP. No logra llenar un CD. Con nuestros genomas tan pequeñitos, la utilidad de compararnos con computadoras se torna bastante poco convincente.

martes, mayo 29, 2007

Who regulates the regulators?

Non-coding "regulatory" sequences are the hot new molecular topic. There is lots of talking about the "overlooked" functionality of non-coding DNA previously assumed to be junk. The evidence is impressive. Micro-RNA's, for instance, can inhibit the expression of a gene with important phenotypic effects. 1 pair base substitutions in non-coding intron sequences, can produce important differences in the expression pattern of a gene and the resulting phenotype.
But are these sequences truly "regulatory", or just another way how the molecular machinery of the cell can be intervened? Even if we show how a base pair change can trigger the appearance of a new expression site for a gene, it still remains that the genome of those cells is the same as that of those where the gene is not expressed. Some difference other than that base pair exists between body regions, that results in the expression or not of the gene. As expected from a systemic awareness, a base pair change can be the trigger for a new expression site: but it does not single-handedly determine or "regulate" the outcome. Local differences are also involved.
Micro-RNA's, for instance, require to be transcribed to have their effect, and as such, are themselves subjected to "regulation" by transcription factors, promoter sequences, and such. This brings us to the question of the title: who regulates the regulator? Is this way of thinking logically correct, if it always ends relaying regulation to a previous mechanism? Are we looking for some sort of central kernel? A great "on" switch?
The observation that the different cells of the body share the same DNA content demonstrates that these differences cannot be reduced to DNA composition, but epigenetic factors are perforce involved (Lillie's Paradox). Taking this into account, it is easy to understand how development is, in fact, epigenesis. Sequences are far from being regulatory: they are participants in a greatly epigenetic process of development.

-Alexander Vargas aka Sander, Alipio